This is my 5th Mathews pair. When I look at my work, casual, formal/event shoes, all of them are Matthews. In the past, I usually ordered 38 and 39 for those with a narrow toe box. For this pair, I clicked 38.... sadly, it was half an inch big. Although this can be remedied, it is a bit uncomfortable on my instep. But as to quality, workmanship, and shipping. I am always a 5-star for Matthews. Since I am always satisfied with everything else. I also appreciate that the online shop offers shoes on sale. Thank you!