This is my 6th pair, I have Matthew's pair for office, casual, and event/party. I usually order 38 and 39 for narrow-toe box design shoes. But this 38 shoe is half an inch bigger, uncomfortable, but manageable. I just have to put a heel stopper. I would always rate this 5 since I truly like the quality, workmanship, and box/shipping. All arrived in good condition. Keep making those comfortable shoes!